Chapter 1 - The Trap Beneath Still Waters
“I know,” Audrey whispered against the crook of my neck, her breath warm, steady, and entirely devoid of the sheer terror she had put on display just thirty seconds ago.
The heat of the late afternoon summer sun suddenly felt like a physical weight pressing down on my scalp. Water dripped from my hair into my eyes, stinging, but I didn't dare blink. Her legs remained securely wrapped around my waist, her fingers splayed flat over my bare shoulders. She wasn't holding on for dear life. She was holding on to be held.
From the patio edge, barely ten feet away, my wife of six years, Rebecca, watched us. Her designer sunglasses rested atop her styled honey-blonde hair, revealing dark, assessing eyes that showed neither anger nor jealousy. Her manicured fingers remained resting lightly beside her iced cold brew on the glass tabletop.
“Rebecca, don’t,” Audrey repeated, her voice cracking now, but this time with genuine fear—a very different fear than the fake panic she had used to drag me into this compromising embrace.
“I told you, Audrey, go ahead,” Rebecca replied, her tone conversational, almost clinical. “Finish what you started. Or did you think Nolan was going to pull back first?”
A sick, cold knot tightened in the pit of my stomach. My arms, which had been automatically bracing Audrey's ribs to keep her head above the surface, dropped instantly to my sides. I took a hard step backward toward the shallow end, peeling Audrey off me with deliberate force. She stumbled, splashing heavily into the waist-deep water, her face as white as a fresh sheet of paper.
“What the hell is going on here?” I demanded, wiping water from my eyes, my voice booming across the quiet suburban backyard. “Both of you. Right now.”
Audrey wouldn’t look at me. She stood in the three-foot shallow section, arms crossed tightly over her chest, shivering violently despite the eighty-five-degree Indiana heat. She looked like a child caught stealing, staring fixatedly at the blue mosaic tiles beneath her feet.
Rebecca slowly pushed herself out of the wicker lounge chair. She smoothed down the hem of her linen sundress, slipped her feet into her slide sandals, and walked deliberately to the edge of the pool coping. She didn’t look furious. She looked victorious.
“Do you want to tell him, Audrey, or should I read the messages you’ve been drafting on your laptop while sitting in my guest bedroom?” Rebecca asked, her voice dropping into that terrifyingly calm register she used whenever she had cornered someone at her corporate consulting job.
“Messages?” I looked between the two sisters. They shared the same high cheekbones and striking amber eyes, but while Rebecca was all sharp angles, ruthless organization, and calculated ambition, Audrey had always been the free-spirited creative—the younger sister who needed a soft place to land after her relationship collapsed and she took a mid-level design job in Carmel. Or so I had thought.
“Nolan, you’re an honest man,” Rebecca said, her gaze finally shifting to me. There was pity in her eyes, mixed with a chilling satisfaction. “You’re reliable, you fix the gutters, you show up on time, and when someone screams for help, you don't think twice before jumping in. That’s why you made such a perfect mark.”
“A mark for what?” My chest heaved. I stepped closer to the edge, looking up at my wife. “Rebecca, what did you just say to her?”
“She didn’t slip, Nolan,” Rebecca said plainly. “She’s been taking private adult swim lessons at the Monon Center every Tuesday and Thursday morning for the last two months. I’ve known for three weeks. She’s an intermediate swimmer. She just needed a physical pretext—an accident where her hands were on you, your hands were on her, and a camera could capture something undeniable.”
Audrey let out a ragged sob, burying her face in wet hands.
“A camera?” I spun around, scanning the yard. The high cedar fence, the neat stone flowerbeds, the brick facade of our two-story home. Then I saw it: nestled behind the dense foliage of the potted hibiscus on the upper deck railing, the faint, glinting circle of an optical lens aimed directly down at the deep end.
May you like
“Who is behind that camera, Rebecca?” I whispered, my pulse hammering in my throat.
Rebecca tilted her head, her smile razor-thin and completely humorless. “The private investigator hired by your business partner, Marcus Vance. Or rather, hired by Audrey on Marcus’s behalf. Tell him, sister. Tell him how much Marcus offered you to give him the leverage he needed to force Nolan out of the firm.”
