Chapter 1 - The Cold Engine Lie
The photographer handed me the glossy print inside a cardboard holiday folder embossed with gold foil snowflakes. Caleb was clutching Hannah’s mitten, both of them staring wide-eyed at the flash, while Daniel’s hand rested on my shoulder like a heavy anchor. In the photo, his lips curved into what looked like a genuine smile. It was the kind of picture you sent to grandparents and tucked into holiday greeting cards with silver ribbons.
""I’ll grab the diaper bag,"" I said, leaning over the twin stroller to buckle Hannah’s five-point harness. Caleb was already kicking his little feet, his cranberry-red booties threatening to slide off onto the polished mall tiles.
Daniel pulled his phone from his coat pocket, tapped the screen twice, and shoved it back into his down jacket. His breath was sharp, his jaw tight. ""Look, the windchill outside is dropping into the teens. Why don't you wait right here by the gingerbread house? It’s warm, and there’s a bench. I’ll run out to the north lot, pull the SUV around to the lower Sears pickup lane, and blast the heater so the babies don't freeze when we buckle them into the car seats.""
A rush of warmth hit my chest. It had been months since Daniel offered to do something thoughtful without me asking three times first. The exhaustion of newborn twins had carved a silent canyon between us, but in that fleeting moment, standing under the artificial boughs of decorated pine, I thought I saw a glimpse of the man I had fallen in love with back in college.
""That would be amazing,"" I said softly, looking up into his hazel eyes. ""Thank you, Daniel. Take my keys—mine are buried at the bottom of the diaper bag.""
""I’ve got the master fob,"" he said quickly, patting his coat. He leaned down and pressed a dry, hurried kiss against my forehead. He didn't look at Caleb or Hannah. He didn't touch their tiny hands. He just turned toward the glass revolving doors leading to the bitter gray afternoon outside.
I watched his black winter jacket disappear into the flow of holiday shoppers carrying shopping bags from Macy’s and bath-and-body shops. A loudspeaker overhead crooned ""Silver Bells,"" the melody sweet and hollow against the murmur of excited children.
I sat down on the wooden green bench beside the exit of Santa’s village. Caleb let out a little yawn, his eyelids drooping under the bright twinkle of thousands of fairy lights strung across artificial arches. Hannah dropped her pacifier onto the stroller tray, and I wiped it clean with a sanitizing cloth from my bag, humming along with the background music.
Ten minutes passed. Then fifteen.
The north parking lot was large, especially on the second Saturday of December, but pulling the car around shouldn't have taken more than eight or nine minutes. I figured the holiday traffic had snarled the entrance loop. Dublin had seen light flurries since noon, and people were notoriously slow drivers in central Ohio during the first snowfall of the season.
At twenty-five minutes, Caleb began to fuss. His diaper was wet, and the cranberry-red outfit was starting to feel scratchy against his neck. I pulled him out of the stroller, resting his warm cheek against my shoulder while rocking him in small, rhythmic circles.
""Daddy’s just getting the car warm, buddy,"" I whispered into his soft brown hair. ""He’ll be right here.""
I pulled my phone from my purse and dialed Daniel’s number. It rang four times before clicking over to his standard voicemail greeting: You’ve reached Daniel Whitmore. Leave a message.
""Hey, hon,"" I said into the recording, keeping my tone light so I wouldn't worry him. ""Caleb is getting a little fussy, and the mall is starting to clear out near the center court. Did you get stuck in the traffic lane? Call me when you’re out front.""
May you like
I hung up, adjusted Hannah’s blanket, and looked back toward the glass doors. Outside, the sky was darkening from pale slate to an ominous twilight, and the wind was rattling the outer double doors with low, whistling groans.
An hour had passed. And Daniel had not called back.
