Chapter 7 - A Brother’s Desperate Confession
Ten minutes passed before anyone spoke again. Martin Abernathy quietly slid the paperwork across the desk, offering Nathan a gold pen. Outside, the rain began to drum against the office windows, a steady, rhythmic cadence that washed over the suffocating room.
“The choice is entirely yours, Nathan,” Martin said softly. “You may sign the acknowledgment of the will and the release form today, which authorizes the immediate transfer of the thirty-five thousand dollars and the title to the shop contents. Or you may retain outside counsel and proceed to court. What is your decision?”
Nathan’s hand hovered above the pen. He looked over at me, his eyes rimmed with red, tears finally spilling freely down his weathered cheeks. The stubborn mask of our father that he had worn since Friday morning had completely shattered.
“Emily,” he choked out, his voice sounding small, like the boy who used to pull my pigtails in the orchard forty years ago. “You don't understand what my life has been. You think I’ve been living high and mighty out west while you two suffered here.”
“No one thought you were living high, Nathan,” I answered gently, leaning across the arm of my chair toward him. “We knew you were struggling. But you never let us help you like a family. You only ever came to us as a conqueror demanding tributes.”
Nathan buried his face in his hands again, his sobs shaking his entire upper body. “I was terrified,” he confessed, the words muffled through his fingers. “When my business collapsed in 2017, I took money from men who don't negotiate. They came to my home. They threatened my girls. Mom saved my life that day on the porch, Emily! She literally saved my life! But I was so ashamed... so utterly sick with shame that I couldn't look Dad in the face ever again.”
Jacob watched him, his posture softening slightly. “So you stayed away.”
“I stayed away because every time Dad looked at me with that proud smile, telling me I was his golden boy, I felt like vomiting,” Nathan wept. “I couldn't confess to him that I was a failure. I couldn't tell him that his favorite son had stolen his mother's retirement. So I hid behind a thousand miles of highway. And then... when Dad died two years ago, I convinced myself that if I just inherited the land, if I just got the farm, I could sell it, pay off everything, and finally be a whole man again.”
“You can't buy your wholeness with another person’s sacrifice, Nathan,” I said, my own tears welling up as I looked at my broken older brother. “Mom didn't cut you out to punish you. If she wanted to punish you, she wouldn't have set aside money for Chloe and Sophia’s college. She wouldn't have left you Dad’s tools. She did this because she loved you too much to let you keep destroying yourself—and us.”
Nathan looked at the legal document before him. He picked up the gold pen, his fingers trembling so violently that the metal clicked against the desk surface. He looked at Martin, then at Jacob, and finally back at me.
“What will you do with the house?” he asked in a whisper.
May you like
“We’re keeping it,” Jacob replied firmly. “We’re fixing the roof Dad never got around to. We’re planting new apple trees in the north orchard. And the guest room will always have a bed made up—if you ever want to come home as a brother instead of a landlord.”
Nathan let out a long, ragged breath that sounded like years of poison leaving his lungs. With slow, deliberate strokes, he pressed the pen to the paper and signed his name across the bottom of the release form.
